...Violence is a privileged access or portal to what is going on in a
society and plays a significant role as to how we relate to ourselves and others.
One must find a way to see beneath the surface, to discover the “real
workings of a society (and ourselves)." The key is not to get caught up in
all the scandals at the surface but persevering through to see beneath the
surface so to track the real life beneath that surface.
Why a
situation is scandalous and not paradoxical is that a paradox is a seeming
contradiction that leads to ever deepening thought, understanding, and love.
Scandals, on the other hand, are blocks to thought, understanding, and love. Good
interpretation is the art of transforming scandals into paradoxes.
Second - Exploring the struggle one encounters when trying to engage in
the art of nonviolence: Alberg's book is vital in guiding us past all the
scandals involved with the “real workings of society” when it comes to violence
and all of its tentacles. It will help in our need to get beneath the surface - to recognize the scandal at the heart of trying to work through violence and to
actually come out the other side to nonviolence... to love your enemies.
One of the keys to seeing beneath the surface is to recognize where one
has expelled the truth; the truth as Christ lived. To help us recognize the
“real workings of society” which has its underpinnings in the human propensity
to expel a scapegoat and the extreme difficulty not to get
trapped by that expulsion, Alberg quotes Nicholas Boyle; “Even in the works and
words that seem to hide God’s face, or to spit on it, we can see God revealed
at the heart of our world and in our culture.”
For this task of going beneath the surface we will rely on the following
tools: a) Interpretative keys that will allow us to go deeper and through scandal, and b)
"soul work" of nonviolence.
I came across a couple "bridges" I hope will help conceptualize
the melding of Christ's message of “Love your enemies” and the tough love of
nonviolence.
Let's begin by meditating deeply on this message from Caryll
Houselander:
I had long been haunted by the Russian conception of the humiliated
Christ, the lame Christ limping through Russia, begging his bread; the Christ
who, all through the ages, might return to the earth and come even to sinners
to win their compassion by His need. Now, in the flash of a second, I
knew that this dream is a fact; not a dream, not the fantasy or legend of
devout people, not the prerogative of the Russians, but Christ in man. Christ in His perfect human nature, Christ
in His risen glory and Christ in His need and His suffering on earth, are
reconciled. We have the whole Christ.
Although this did not prevent me from ever sinning again, it showed me
what sin is, especially those sins... so often held to be “harmless” – for to
sin with one whom you loved (or against another) was to blaspheme Christ in
that person, it was to spit on Him, perhaps to crucify Him.
I saw too the reverence that everyone must have for a sinner; instead of
condoning his sin, which is in reality his utmost sorrow, one must comfort Christ who is suffering in him. And this reverence must be paid even to those sinners whose
souls seem to be dead, because it is Christ, who is the life of the soul, who
is dead in them; they are His tombs, and Christ in the tomb is potentially the
risen Christ. For the same reason,
no one of us who has fallen into mortal sin himself must ever lose hope.
This is an example of an author going beneath the surface and being able
to feel the pulse of what Christ would call Kingdom Reality.
What grabs me here is that she is saying that Christ is abiding in our
friend, our enemy and making sure not to forget that Christ abides in one's
very self as well. When we sin, we are crucifying Christ in our very
selves and we somehow need to find a way to reconcile with Christ within
ourselves. And when we engage with another sinner we need to not only recognize
but come to the aid of the suffering Christ within the other, even though they
may mistreat you and debase you. For as they sin against you they sin against
Christ, within you as well as within themselves. And it is our
commission to love Christ even in others who, knowingly of not, through their
actions, are attempting to expel Christ, becoming His tomb, "and Christ in
the tomb is potentially the risen Christ."
So, can we
apply this "soul work" of going beyond the scandal, loving our enemy,
seeing Christ within the person who is spitting at you or abusing you? What
sort of belief system, discipline or training does it take to stand in the
place of abuse, totally open to receiving Christ at that very moment, so to be
Christ for another?
I hope in this "sit-in" clip from,
The Butler, we might be able to observe where we are expelling Christ, where we are sinning against one another and Christ and to recognize "Christ in the tomb" where the potentially risen Christ exists.